Not our finest hour on drugs

Stephen J goes against the political flow at The Standard on the sudden rush to ban currently legal psychoactive substances, saying “there has been a moral panic based on nothing more than a few horror stories in the press“.

I don’t think this is our finest hour, to be honest. We should be aspiring to evidence based policy that aims at harm minimisation. There has been a moral panic based on nothing more than a few horror stories in the press. Great TV showing Dunne all shocked in Naenae, why can’t we see Collins in the emergency room on a Saturday night looking at the alcohol damage?

Now we’ve let ourselves get suckered into taking a position that will be difficult to unwind into a rational policy. Grrr.

He suggests the right questions were not asked or addressed.

The drugs in question are only legal under an interim regime which will expire soon. The MOH could actually have withdrawn them already and it would be very interesting to know why they have not — if the MSM weren’t busy hyperventilating that would have been a good question to ask.

Either the evidence isn’t there or MoH is falling down on the job.

The Psychoactive Substances Regulatory Authority is already able to ban substances deemed harmful:

40 (1) The Authority may, at any time, by notice in the Gazette, revoke an approval of a psychoactive product granted under section 37 if the Authority considers on reasonable grounds that the product poses more than a low risk of harm to individuals using the product.

The NZ Drug Foundation is also asking why this hasn’t been used – see Politicians playing silly buggers on drugs?

Stephen J continues:

Another interesting question is where all the horror cases were before the law was passed, as the substances concerned were already being sold. At least now they are in packaging with the Poison Centre hotline on it and good labelling about the contents!

The legislative framework isn’t perfect but it is adequate and better than what we had or what most jurisdictions have. Good things were coming of it. We’ve been banning these things for years, and they just get replaced with substances with no testing at all. At least in the present case there would have been a testing regime coming.

Your whole response takes for granted that there is a widespread problem that we had to respond to quickly, and that there was no answer within the present law. I don’t agree with either of these propositions.

We lack anything but anecdotal evidence in the media for evidence. We wouldn’t make policy in other areas based on a few high profile cases and I don’t see why this is different. The MoH could have withdrawn these substances if there was immediate concern (why haven’t they?) or we could have waited for the interim approvals to expire and the testing regime to kick in.

Finally, harm minimisation isn’t just about the health effects of a substance but also about whether people substitute with worse substances, or get entangled with the criminal justice system and so on.

If you want to go JUST THINK OF THE CHILDREN and let tabloid coverage dictate what you do, fine. I can’t support that. It’s PR-driven, knee-jerk policy. If it weren’t an election year we wouldn’t even be having this conversation.

Moral panic plus election year panic leading to rushed legal high bans leaves me feeling wonder how well thought through this is, and makes me uneasy about what will happen.

If there are a lot of addicts out there, and if withdrawal effects are as bad as has been portrayed in the media, the sudden halt of availability may cause more problems than we currently have.

Are the police, health and rehab facilities ready to act as fast as the politicians?

Leave a comment

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s