Little’s big reshuffle

Andrew Little has played his caucus reshuffle cars well, with some risks (there’s always risks).

1. Andrew Little
Leader of the Opposition
Security and Intelligence

2. Annette King
Deputy Leader
Health

Good move having King as deputy, keeps some continuity with a lot of experience and should help get the Caucus onside and supportive.

3. Grant Robertson
Finance

A big play. Robertson wanted a top job, this isn’t what he wanted but this is perhaps next best. It will be a real test of his ability. If he doesn’t measure up Little has a couple of ex Finance spokespeople sulking but in a year may be ready to perform.

4. Nanaia Mahuta
Maori Development

Reward/conciliation here. Mahuta needs to show she can perform far more visibly and effectively than she has so far.

5. Phil Twyford
Housing
Transport

Not sure about this one, maybe he’ll be good enough. There’s one way to find out.

6. Chris Hipkins
Shadow Leader of the House
Senior Whip
Education
Early Childhood Education

A good promotion of new blood, Hipkins has to learn to lead and not work in the shadow of fellow henchmen.

7. Carmel Sepuloni
Social Development
Junior Whip

I have no idea how she will go with this sort of promotion and only just back in Parliament.

8. Kelvin Davis
Police
Corrections
Associate Justice (Sexual and Domestic Violence)
Associate Education (Maori Education)
Associate Regional Development

A good move. One Labour candidate/MP with fairly wide support and respect and he eliminated a pesky Mana left flank for Labour.

9. Jacinda Ardern
Justice
Children
Small Business
Arts, Culture, Heritage

Nowhere near where she wanted (deputy to Robertson) but lucky to get a chance under Little, she’s been a bit lightweight. If she performs she could replace King in a year – is she being mentored for this?

10. David Clark
Economic Development
Associate Finance
Associate Health (Mental Health)

Maybe in his second term he realises that hard work is necessary and he’ll be prepared for serious debate.

11. Su’a William Sio
Pacific Island Affairs
Local Government
Associate Housing (South Auckland)
Interfaith Dialogue

Reward for PI support. I don’t know if he otherwise deserves it.

12. Iain Lees-Galloway
Labour

Could be part of the new wave but needs to improve.

13. Megan Woods
Environment
Climate Change

Some rate her but I haven’t seen it. Her demeanour in Parliament hasn’t impressed, too angry/snarky.

14. David Cunliffe
Regional Development
Tertiary Education
Research and Development
Science and Innovation
Associate Economic Development

A fair placement for him. He needs to prove he can work hard with a team.

15. David Parker
Trade and Export Growth
Shadow Attorney General
Treaty of Waitangi Negotiations

Also fair placement after his sulking in failure. He has to prove he wants to help the cause or drop out.

16. David Shearer
Foreign Affairs
Consumer Affairs

Seems to be good with Foreign Affairs but not so good with party affairs.

17. Phil Goff
Defence
Veterans’ Affairs
Disarmament
Auckland Issues
Ethnic Affairs

About here he should be, if he wants to put the effort it.

UNRANKED MPS

Trevor Mallard:
Assistant Speaker 
Internal Affairs (excluding Gambling)
Sport and Recreation
Animal Rights
Parliamentary Reform

He might be better with his Assistant Speaker role requiring a more responsible performance – if he can leave his dirty politics in the past.

Ruth Dyson
Conservation
Senior Citizens
Disability Issues
Canterbury Earthquake Recovery

There for experience, not for future prospects.

Damien O’Connor
Primary Industries
Biosecurity
Food Safety

Not likely to rise to greater heights.

Clayton Cosgrove
Revenue
SOEs
Building and Construction
Earthquake Commission
Associate Finance

Significant demotion deserved. He campaigned for electorate vote and blatantly ignored party responsibilities, and a fairly toxic brand that Labour needs to leave on the past.

Sue Moroney
ACC
Immigration
Women’s Affairs
Associate Labour

She hasn’t been stellar but I don’t know why she’s been slid backwards so much. Mustn’t be seen as a future prospect.

Little has made some major changes. Labour needs major change.

Putting them on notice that  all positions are up for review in a year is smart – Little needs to change things but needs to not aggravate old and recent wounds too much as he gets himself established.

If the polls have recovered enough he will be able to assess things and then act decisively this time next year to prepare a credible team for the election in 2017.

Little has played his first hand with a good balance of old and new, carrot and stick. It’s up to all of them to step up.

Leave a comment

14 Comments

  1. Overall a good call.. as they are all on a 12 month trial (except Little ?) it will interesting to see whether they all step up & most are still in these/similar roles in 2016 ?
    I just wonder whether Little should look to pull together a broad opposition/coalition arrangement; offering some ‘spokesperson’ roles to other party MPs (Greens & NZ first) too ?

    Reply
    • Mike C

       /  24th November 2014

      Sadly for Little Andy, he is the one and only Labour Party Caucus Member who is truely on trial over the next year, Zedd. LOL.

      Reply
    • Little talked about building relationships with Greens and NZ First, and clearly signaling preferred coalition arrangements prior to the election. That would fix one of Labour’s mistakes this year.

      Reply
    • Mike C

       /  24th November 2014

      I gave you an up tick, Zedd.
      But the system gave you a down vote.
      It won’t let me change it. Very sorry 😦
      You are different to me, opinion-wise.
      But I still respect what you say Zedd 🙂

      Reply
  2. Sponge

     /  24th November 2014

    Little has appeared to be worryingly competent in the short time he has been in charge. There is plenty of time for him to fail yet of course, and those who he has demoted will be looking to extract their revenge, but what I have heard of him on radio he has come across as sincere, said and articulate. Which is more than be said for his 3 predecessors.

    Reply
    • The stark contrast makes him look good.

      A key difference is he sounds like he’s saying what he thinks and what he wants to do, and hasn’t taken a month to learn lame slogans that then get repeated over and over.

      He has quite a different style to Key but has a similar way of sounding like he’s on top of things and speaks his own words.

      Reply
      • and also in stark contrast to the ‘other one’ who used to say different things to different audiences on the same subject.

        Reply
    • Sponge

       /  24th November 2014

      Sorry that shaped be “sincere, sane and articulate”

      Reply
      • Sponge

         /  24th November 2014

        Arrghh. *should be*

        This mac auto correct is driving me nuts! Though in fairness my proof reading leaves a lot to be desired.

        Any joy on being able to edit posts Pete?

        Reply
        • Not yet. Tomorrow I’m going to Aus for the rest of the week, I’ll do what blogging i can but won’t have much time so will look into it more next week.

          Reply
  3. Mike C

     /  24th November 2014

    A couple of days ago, I thought Little Andy sounded quite believable.

    In the interim, I’ve changed my mind.

    Andrew Little has no sense of humour.

    Whose gonna vote for someone who can’t laugh at normal everyday stuff, let alone at themselves.

    Reply
    • You mean like Mr Key.. who just makes a joke of everything; even somethings that are clearly NOT funny (eg escaped prisoners).. :<

      Reply
      • Mike C

         /  25th November 2014

        I just prefer politicians who have a sense of humour, Zedd.

        John Key can deliver some really funny off the cuff quips to the opposition during the Parliamentary Q&A time.

        Little is a big bore-fest. LOL.

        Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s