Jumping the Whale, piling on Godwin and hypocrisy

While the main victims were those killed and injured in the Christchurch mosque attacks, and their families  and friends and the Muslim community, but it also impacted on wider New Zealand.

But some are taking Government reactions to the attacks as gross over-reactions, and are claiming themselves to be victims as the country as we know it is coming to an end. Some have jumped the shark, likening the aftermath to Nazi Germany in the 1930s.

From one day at Whale Oil (yesterday):

Guest Post (Mike Loder): What reasonable person would accept this?

Media next hailed the ‘Responsible shooter’ for handing in his gun. For the public good. They left out the part where he is a Green Party candidate and hates guns. Details. Goebbels would blush at the propaganda forced on a caring population this past week.

Hart was a Green candidate in 2017 but isn’t now. He handed in a rifle not a gun (a technicality, but something most people into firearms would know) . I have seen nothing in any of the reports about John Hart handing in his semi-automatic rifle that he ‘hates guns’. He had owned the rifle for about ten years and just handed it in on principle of removing the most dangerous firearms from circulation.  CNN reported:

He said he had purchased the semi-automatic firearm to help with killing goats and wild pigs to aid in pest control on the farm. Hart said he still has other guns on the farm for “chores and euthanizing animals.”

He still owns ‘other guns’, not a sign of hate.

There is unlikely to be any blushing at Whale Oil over the propaganda they have published, but there should be.

Christie We should all walk away from social media

The overreaction to the Christchurch massacre continues.

Notably at Whale Oil.

Duncan Garner thinks that, because he allowed social media to run his life, we all do that, but he is wrong. Not everyone who drinks wine is an alcoholic. Some people can manage these things in moderation. Because Duncan Garner cannot do that, he wants social media to be banned for the rest of us.

We really do seem to be living in Germany in the 1930s, don’t we?

There is nothing quoted in the post that supports the claim that Garner wants social media banned.

SB:  I’m scared of our government

The post is headed with a photo captioned “Georges Blind, a member of the French resistance, smiling at a German firing squad, October 1944.”

In only a couple of weeks, the most unimaginable things have started happening. I feel like I am living in an Orwellian novel and I keep waiting and hoping for a political hero like President Trump to stand up and protect New Zealand.

Censorship has come out of left field, and media are leading the charge to control what can and can’t be discussed. Stasi-like vigilante groups are being formed to spy on New Zealanders and to add them to lists.

Censorship has been a round for a long time – and has been used extensively at Whale Oil since 2014 to to control what can and can’t be discussed there.

Organisations, as well as individuals, are going to be accused of hate speech or of being hate groups and people are going to be metaphorically lined up against a wall and shot (deplatformed) by the thought-police.

Will my future grandchildren be able to read my articles or will they and I disappear down the memory hole? How long will it be before I am labelled a dissident and a non-person? It is not only bullets that can destroy a person.

The most likely reason SB’s articles will disappear will be as a result of legal and financial holes dug and dug deeper by her husband Cameron Slater, who is finding that abusing social media power and stupidity, and failing accept responsibility and instead claiming to be a victim, can contribute to self destruction.

A comment by Opal:

It’s the same feeling of unreality that must have been in Nazi Germany of 1930s. It fooled many Jewish citizens – this couldn’t happen in cultured civilized Germany.

“Nazi Germany of 1930s” seems to be a theme, if not a meme.



Leave a comment


  1. Griff.

     /  29th March 2019

    Whale Oil.
    Echo chamber for the terminally deluded projecting their behavour on the rest of us.

    • Corky

       /  29th March 2019

      That echo has grown louder. Lots more people posting there now. A consequence of our Nations overreaction?

      ”Echo chamber for the terminally deluded projecting their behaviour on the rest of us.”

      Actually it’s the other way around.

    • Conspiratoor

       /  29th March 2019

      Projecting their behaviour on you. You poor petal. Give me a break!

  2. Corky

     /  29th March 2019

    I think you posted a good rebuttal to the Whaleoil culture, Pete.

    It boils down to who is right…you or them. I cannot envisage an in between state.

    The arbiter who is right wil be time. And the tangent our nation now embarks on.

  3. duperez

     /  29th March 2019

    It is disappointing the most likely reason SB’s articles will disappear from Whale Oil will be because of legal and financial problems of her husband. It would be good if they disappeared because they are so stupid they are not worth hearing.

    • Corky

       /  29th March 2019

      I think you are the type of person Whalers fear, Duperez. Me too.

    • Dave K

       /  29th March 2019

      “It would be good if they disappeared because they are so stupid they are not worth hearing.”

      Yep, goddam deplorables…..how dare they venture forth their ill-informed opinions. Why don’t they just go back to their (…..not sure we have trailer parks so select alternative descriptor…batches?, cribs?, rugby clubs?, RSAs?, talkback radio?).

      That approach worked out so gooood in ‘ol US didn’t it y’all (…and it seems in the original Zeeland in more recent times).

      • Kitty Catkin

         /  29th March 2019

        Caravan parks ? baches and sleepouts ?

        Well, some people still listen to talkback…..

    • Conspiratoor

       /  29th March 2019

      “they are so stupid they are not worth hearing”

      What makes you so damn clever you think your opinions are worth hearing

  4. phantom snowflake

     /  29th March 2019

  1. Farrar responds to Christchurch attacks and Kiwiblog content | Your NZ

Leave a Reply to Conspiratoor Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: