A story of ‘political skulduggery’ in Marlborough from Stuff: Marlborough councillors brand Whale Oil leak ‘despicable’
Political skulduggery has again rocked the council chamber in Marlborough as lawyers are called in to investigate a secret recording of a committee meeting leaked to a right-wing blog.
The leak to Whale Oil could see heads roll at the council, as councillors who attended the meeting are made to front up on Monday.
A recording of a tense behind closed doors discussion about the cash-strapped ASB Theatre was published on the blog site on Friday.
Council chief executive Mark Wheeler said if a councillor had leaked the public-excluded discussion he or she could be asked to resign.
The committee meeting took place in April.
Councillor Peter Jerram said the leak was “absolutely orchestrated” and smacked of “dirty politics” emerging in Marlborough.
“Party politics are definitely involved. But worse than that, it’s gutter politics.”
Marlborough Mayor Alistair Sowman said the post was a clear attack on mayoral frontrunner Leggett, after a “very successful” attack on Sowman himself.
Whale Oil involved in local body politics in Marlborough might seem a bit odd, they don’t usually do much about the provinces and most will have no idea who the current mayor of Marlborough is and who the candidates are.
But Whale Oil has had a number of posts on Marlborough local body politics over the last few months. Why? The Stuff article has a hint.
Political strategist Simon Lusk, who has links to Whale Oil, spoke at a local government seminar in Marlborough earlier this year attended by several council candidates.
Lusk said at the time fighting for transparency was meaningless unless candidates opposed bad news being hidden in publicly excluded council meetings.
Lusk did not confirm or deny whether he was involved when contacted on Saturday.
He was told information had come through on the blog’s tip line, he said.
Why Lusk or Whale Oil might have such an interest in Marlborough local body politics is anyone’s guess.
There’s an unusual number of posts on Marlborough issues at Whale Oil going back to about June. No other regions have had this much attention so they stood out.
I never took much notice of the Marlborough posts apart from noticing they were there, they seemed local and not very interesting.
But what we have now is a story of wider interest:
- a secret recording of a closed Marlborough District Council meeting in April
- details of the recording published on Whale Oil in September, on the day that local body election voting papers are sent out
- council chief executive Mark Wheeler said if a councillor had leaked the public-excluded discussion he or she could be asked to resign
Being asked to resign three weeks before the election closes might be horse bolted timing.
What if the leaker is a candidate for the election? Their name is already printed on the ballot and posted to voters, but it could affect votes.
The Marlborough Express (Stuff) has followed up with Marlborough council announces investigation into Whale Oil leak ahead of final meeting
A secret recording of a private council meeting has triggered an investigation into all councillors and staff who were at the meeting.
The investigation will require everyone at the behind closed doors discussion in Marlborough to sign a statutory declaration saying they were not behind the recording or it being leaked to a right-wing blog.
It is a criminal offence to knowingly make a false declaration.
They are taking it very seriously.
Meanwhile Whale Oil had a string of posts on it yesterday too.
As predicted yesterday the Marlborough Express has written an attack piece on me. They didn’t even call for comment.
After we busted John Leggett and the Marlborough Express tried to ignore the story there still remain a number of unanswered questions that I am sure the ratepayers of Marlborough wants answers to.
The Marlbourgh Express doesn’t seem to know the first rule of politics. Explaining is losing.
That’s funny considering the number of posts explaining everything.
Locals don’t dare speak out because their lives will be made hell. Local news doesn’t dare speak up because their commercial viability is under threat if they speak up against their biggest advertisers.
More explaining. They could be important issues for people in Marlborough, but that’s local stuff that most people are unlikely to be interested in.
So they act like they are violated, scream “Whaleoil” and hope that voters will forget what it is really all about.
What an utter waste of rate payers’ money to try and figure out who helped the truth get to the public.
Stop screaming my name, and start taking responsibility for your own words and actions.
That’s more interesting, to me anyway.
A secret recording was taken of a closed door council meeting and supplied to a media outlet and published during an election campaign.
The recording is a serious matter. If it was a councillor they could be asked to resign. If it was a staff member I expect it would potentially be a sackable offence.
But Cameron Slater and Whale Oil don’t think that how the information was obtained matters, or is excusable as the story they want to tell is what is important.
Nicky Hager thought something similar when he published Dirty Politics.
Another thing that puzzles me about this – how much influence would Whale Oil have on the Marlborough election?
Most people are barely or not interested in local body elections. Most Marlborough voters are unlikely to read Whale Oil.
I’m baffled as to why Whale Oil is giving so much coverage over several months for a relatively low interest issue that can hardly be attracting many clicks or much advertising to the blog.
It will be interesting to see whether Whale Oil sees their whistle blowing coverage of sufficient importance and interest to continue their coverage after the election.